Sorry, but I personally believe the way you handle conflict (especially those that involve people that are not your close friends) found within chat is inappropriate.
Sometimes you even add unnecessary fuel to the fire outside of chat, too. Even if it is just for laughs, mildly trolling users as opposed to ending chat conflict is not something mod-like to me, even if said users were troublemakers in the first place.
While you're an awesome person, I have yet to see you neutral in anything.
I'd hate to make it seem like I'm jumping onto a bandwagon, but
I vote NO on this.
Chames and Mantis summed it up pretty well. It's also worth noting that I have never once seen you try to resolve something rationally or neutrally. Of course, this may not mean much given how rarely I'm on the chat, but I've known you for several years and this still remains true. You seem to have a bit of an ego and like to walk all over people like Nick. Basically anybody who makes a big claim about their character being super strong in your presence, you like to get right up in their faces to prove them wrong in an RP fight (not too much wrong about that, but still,) or if they godmodded around/against you, I've almost never seen you let them live it down.