User blog comment:Kagimizu/Broken/@comment-27765057-20121227193345

Here's the problem:

If we truly had to vote on the call based on what happened between Kagi, Guy, and Shou, then most of us wouldn't be able to vote in the first place. A lot of us weren't there at the time, and those who were didn't even bother voting or weren't available to vote. So, the fact that Memph was trying to get us to vote based on the evidence was a bit unfair for the majority of users.