Board Thread:Wiki Improvement/@comment-5518179-20150119033836

Since I feel like the goal to SFW's future success is being as user-friendly as possible, I considered potentially adding Message Walls and Article Comments, however, such a thing is too much of a change to be simply done without the community permission, so I'm going to make this a voting/suggestion thread.

I will first explain why I feel the need for these two.
 * Talk pages become cluttered, and you're never notified when someone replies to you back on THEIR talk page.
 * Many new users don't understand how talk pages work.
 * They eventually get too long and unmanageable, with message walls/article comments you can see who replies, and there is no need for a signature, (doesn't mean you don't need to post one.)

If anyone is willing to add to that, I'll add it, now, as far as the reasons against them.
 * Talk pages are a vital function that many users are not willing to take away.
 * They allow the use of signatures without looking off.
 * You can easily clear your entire talk page as opposed to message walls.

Now, I promised this would be a voting thread at the same time, but I'm willing to make this is a poll instead of an actual voting thread.

Here's the rules on this. Two polls regarding the adding of articles comments and message walls. If you want them, vote yes, if you don't, vote no. I'll implement the features, or another admin will, if the 'yes' category gets 66.67% or more votes than no in the next two weeks.

If any admins feel this violates the policy in any way, feel free to consult to me about it, and I'll be willing to come up with a consensus/voting thread.

Anyways, remember to vote and remember to suggest!

Should Article Comments be Added? Yes No

Should Message Walls be Added? Yes No  