Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-97.82.153.89-20130113023446/@comment-27984457-20170516185328

Well, Silver beat Sonic no problem and Shadow's technically done so (although you could say when he did it wasn't canon), so he's out of the question. Shadow and Silver fought each other to a standstill in 06, but by the look of that fight it looks more like Shadow just from sheer experience.