Forum:Featured Article Nominations



Nominations for Featured Article status should be recorded below. Each new entry should be placed AT THE BOTTOM of the page, just before the template. Note that, should a draw occur, the nominator's support vote will not be counted. For a complete set of rules, see Forum:Featured Articles.

Note that ONLY FAN CHARACTERS AND RELATED MATERIAL may be nominated. Characters, games and locations already existing, such as Sonic the Hedgehog, Sonic Heroes and Mobius, may not be nominated. Exceptions may be possible if existing in a parallel dimension or reality.

Remember to add this template to any article you nominate. AND remember you can nominate YOUR OWN ARTICLES as well, but only ONE.
 * New rule in effect. Users may nominate three of their own articles, and can vote for one of them as well. Only one, though.

NOTICE: Articles MUST meet Policy Standards to be accepted. If an article is nominated without meeting the standard quality, it will be removed. If a page is still under construction, it can only be accepted if it meets the policy standards of an unfinished article.

Questions and suggestions may be asked in the Head of Featured Article's office. The current Head is Smash The Echidna.

The new featured article will be revealed on the 31th of March.

Current Tally
Sanctuarian Runes
 * (3 For / 0 Against) = 3

Adam The Hedgehog Cold the Hedgehog
 * (1 For / 1 against) = 0
 * (1 For / 2 against) = -1

Smash The Echidna
 * (5 For / 0 Against) = 5

Splice The Hedgehog (RPG Fangame) Matthias the Crystal Dreamer Sergeant Death Savant the Goetian
 * (1 For / 0 Against) = 1
 * (5 For / 0 Against) = 5
 * (13 For / 2 Against) = 11
 * (3 For / 0 Against) = 3

Sanctuarian Runes
Nominator: User:Hunter1034
 * Comments: [Chuckles] While I don't expect this to outdo any character pages, I figured it was worth a shot. The Sanctuarian Runes are the basis of a highly flexible system of magic which I designed with the prospect of other users using. As such I stove to perfect the balance of structure and customization so it wouldn't be considered overpowered by being too free form or too strict for anyone to really be interested. Personally, I think I got it right. :3

Supporters: User:Hunter1034, User:Juely, OmegaEdge ZX
 * Comments: Pretty detailed page. I always liked ancient technologies in the Sonic universe. Juely 13:47, March 2, 2012 (UTC)


 * I like this page, because of it's attension to detail and the like, it covers basically everything you to know, and more!

Objectors:
 * Comments:

Adam the Hedgehog
Nominator:Tailsman67

Comments: The father of Cold the Hedgehog is finally here from when he was thought of in 2008. ._. Tailsman67 20:41, March 2, 2012 (UTC)

Supporters:Tailsman67,Sonic1000

Comments:

Objectors: User:Hunter1034

Comments:
 * What now HUNTER?Tailsman67 15:52, March 7, 2012 (UTC)
 * He has a cookie cutter personality, his page doesn't use proper English, I couldn't get a good mental picture of him due the description you gave on his page, nor do I really know what any of his abilities other than he can freeze his own blood in order to use it as a weapon and that he possesses "superhuman strength, speed and reflexes" on top of something you simply refer to as "energy waves." The page's format is poorly done, half of it being red, and from what I can tell, he's yet another overpowered character who may or may not be a Marty-Stu created by you. I don't know because I couldn't stomach the red text on top of the poor grammar.


 * As such, I respectfully object to this page's nomination. The Crusader hath return-ed!  17:05, March 7, 2012 (UTC)
 * Tailsman, you should know that you cannot be a supporter for two of your own nominations . Only one . Choose which one you want to support. ~Smash The Echidna~ http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100421224452/sonicfanon/images/0/04/Smash_life.png 01:42, March 8, 2012 (UTC)


 * While I do object this character, like Hunter said, you can only nominate at least once. Plus, you cannot use someone else's username just to increase your vote, as I have not seen Sonic1000 made any decision on whether to support or object your characters.   "Rainbow Dash"  --130367835016.png-- "Ohai thar." 19:45, March 8, 2012 (UTC)


 * After looking at the history I find that Jon is right, Sonic1000 hasn't decided to support your character's nomination; he hasn't even edited the page! Unless an admin or 'crat objects I'm removing Sonic1000's support for both your nominations and calling them void. The Crusader hath return-ed!  20:54, March 8, 2012 (UTC)
 * I must point out that there was a new rule added above. You CAN nominate more than once, but you can only support ONE of your own nominations. Which leads me to reminding Tailsman that he can't be a supporter for both Cold and Adam.~Smash The Echidna~ http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100421224452/sonicfanon/images/0/04/Smash_life.png 22:17, March 8, 2012 (UTC)


 * First he is not as strong as anyone elses chars,second I live with Sonic1000,so I know his vote.Tailsman67 17:21, March 13, 2012 (UTC)
 * No, he's stronger than some of them. As for you "living" with Sonic1000, your point is still void: They themselves must come and add their support for your page, because for all we know you could be lying. The Crusader hath return-ed!  20:07, March 13, 2012 (UTC)
 * You ain't his bro so hush,and he is not overpowerd,you just want to pick on me.Tailsman67 20:33, March 14, 2012 (UTC)
 * No, I will not "hush" because you have not given any proof as to his living with you, and even then his "vote" is void until he himself comes on here and shows his support. Furthermore, if I were to try and "pick on you" I would do it in a much more direct manner. All I have said was that you character is overpowered and under-described, nothing aimed at you as a user. The Crusader hath return-ed!  21:01, March 14, 2012 (UTC)
 * I would like to see how he is overpowered,also I will get S1000.Tailsman67 21:11, March 14, 2012 (UTC)
 * Come on guys. Is this arguing gonna keep happening every month. Tailsman, here's a wordof advice on typing: when you put a comma and then a word (Rayman) be sure to put a space  in between the two. I'll look over the page. BlurayOriginals 21:15, March 14, 2012 (UTC)


 * what am i hear for?Sonic1000 21:17, March 14, 2012 (UTC)


 * You are here to formally show your support for your "brother's" character, so we can actually count you as a supporter. As for overpoweredness you state that Adam possesses "superhuman strength, speed and reflexes" in his article, which makes a reader believe that he is on par with or surpasses Sonic and Knuckles in these areas. Furthermore, you state that he can use something called "energy waves" without giving any sort of description, so I immediately assume they are highly powerful. And this on top of his "Ice staff" and appearant high fighting skills and I see him as an overpowered character. The Crusader hath return-ed!  21:48, March 14, 2012 (UTC)
 * Hmmm... BlurayOriginals 21:51, March 14, 2012 (UTC)

Skate the Hedgehog
Nominator:Tailsman67

Comments: I finish his page,yay!Tailsman67 20:35, March 14, 2012 (UTC)

Supporters:Sonic1000

Comments:

Objectors:

Comments:

Cold the Hedgehog
Nominator:Tailsman67,Sonic1000 21:30, March 14, 2012 (UTC)

Comments: The father and son. ._. Tailsman67 20:41, March 2, 2012 (UTC)

Supporters:Tailsman67

Comments:

Objectors: User:Hunter1034, Jon, Scrounder

Comments:

I'm sorry, but I have yet to see any proper grammar about this character. It's still too overpowered in my eyes.   "Rainbow Dash"  ---- "Ohai thar." 19:43, March 8, 2012 (UTC)

Sorry, but like Jon said, he's too overpowered. Again, sorry, Tailsman. -- Heros in a  halfshell  20:40, March 13, 2012 (UTC)

Smash The Echidna
Nominator: Smash
 * Comments: I've decided to try again with Smash, seeing how the whole Featured Articles deal is under control now. I want to see how he does legitimately, no interferences or any kinda weird things happening or whatever.

Supporters: Ryushu, Johnny, VegasFox,User:Tailsman67, Minato   Arisato
 * Comments:


 * 1) Weird things happening? Too late, the text already turned green.
 * 2) I noticed, and now I know exactly what happened. Scrounder's sig is screwed up, and it's color leaked out all over the place. ~Smash The Echidna~ http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100421224452/sonicfanon/images/0/04/Smash_life.png 03:23, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
 * I think I fixed it --Ryu


 * As much as I hate giving out the much needed details about this character, it is well-written, greatly detailed and has excellence in quality.   "Rainbow Dash"  --130367835016.png-- "Ohai thar." 03:29, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
 * Do I have to say why? He's amazing I say let 'em in :D

Thanks you guys. ^^ ~Smash The Echidna~ http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100421224452/sonicfanon/images/0/04/Smash_life.png 04:20, March 3, 2012 (UTC)

Sorry about the green text, everyone. I'm gonna try to fix that. -- Scrounder

Just because you didn't vote for me doesn't mean I won't vote for you buddy ^^ Tailsman67 19:58, March 6, 2012 (UTC) Objectors:
 * Comments:

Splice The Hedgehog (RPG Fangame)
Nominator: Smash Please give me your honest opinions.
 * Comments: I have been working on this game for a long time now. I may have taken many breaks and put this on hiatus several times, but it's still coming along. I don't really update the page as much as I used to, and I have a feeling that the general layout of it may need work, but I have confidence in this game now. I know there's a lot to be done, but bear with me--It's really just one person working on it. (Kapus actually hasn't contributed in months, aside from general advice.)

Supporters: Smash
 * Comments:

Objectors:

Matthias the Crystal Dreamer
 Nominator: Makuta294


 * Comments: I'm gonna nominate Matt again cause in the last nomination, I felt he was ignored but I know there was an issue going on or something so i think that was why Matt was ignored. In the last nomination, a user told me that I should get a drawn picture for Matt instead of using the furry doll maker one. I'm currently working on that because his current picture is not how he looks now. Other than the picture, I feel Matt should be nominated because of his history, how well he was made, and originality.

Supporters: makuta294, UltraStar18, ZeroPath, Ryushu, Hikaruyami-having fun*


 * Comments:

Objectors:

Sergeant Death
Nominator: Minato   Arisato

Comments: I want to nominate Sarge because I feel I've worked hard on him and the character is actually ready for nomination. I know I have done many wrong things with Sarge, but that has all been edited. I want to also Nominate him for more popularity. Before his new design I've felt sarge was bland, so please tell me if you think he is ready. I feel he should be nominated because of his history and strong personality change.

Supporters: Wolf, Ryushu, Boombomb, Needle, UltraStar18 ,Mr.Zaya, ZeroPath ,Stardust327, Precursor Daxter!, Sonicthehedgehog1515,Zombie, Hikaruyami-having fun*, DARKEST PART OF THE STORM


 * Comments:

Objectors: Kagi mizu -Seeya 'round  Vegas the Fox Hybrid; Emotion's Final Release  20:34, March 13, 2012 (UTC)


 * Comments:
 * -The content is hardly equal to that of most of the other articles nominated. IMHO, it seems very obvious that this article is getting votes for the popularity of the user, rather than the quality of the content. I have nothing against Ult whatsoever, but I honestly think it would be quite the fallacy if Sergeant Death won over some of the other articles nominated at this time.--Kagi mizu -Seeya 'round 20:11, March 13, 2012 (UTC)


 * I have to agree with Kagi, the main reason I didn't comment on this was because I was neutral about how to approach this. The fact that it's a self drawn article and all is good and all, but the information is a bit lacking. I'm assuming that the reason to this mass attack of votes is because of the popularity of the user like Kagi said and maybe the way he RP's as a character. But compared to everything else here, I have to agree that this article doesn't meet my requirments as an amazing one in my eyes. Although this is personal opinion, he has the capability to be a big character but right now I can't fully agree to this character's win :/ The amount of votes he has also seems a bit unrealistic, it seems a bit forced or asked upon. <font color="blue" size="2px">Vegas the Fox Hybrid; Emotion's Final Release [[File:Vegas icon by djyoshi25-d4rl235.gif]] 20:34, March 13, 2012 (UTC)
 * Thank you for the honesty I can understand how you two feel but I feel as if I've poored my heart into this article. I will touch up on what you guys want me to edit and other things that make the article unatractive. I really do want to touch and I can definately agree the votes are unrealistic but I really don't like forcing people to do what I want so in no way do I intend just tell people to vote for my ariticle because they are my friends (ETC). Thank you for the review on its vote I was actually anticipating objectors I really like the honesty. Minato  Arisato  02:47, March 14, 2012 (UTC)

Savant the Goetian
Nominator: Ryushu
 * Comments: Since Savant didn't get that much recognition last time, let's try this again.

Supporters: Ryushu, Jon, Minato   Arisato, Hunter
 * Comments:

Objectors:
 * 1) Well... I can't give out an explanation. This character is just too awesome for obvious reasons. Definite positive. <font style="Matisse ITC">  "Rainbow Dash"  --130367835016.png-- "Ohai thar." 22:12, March 8, 2012 (UTC)
 * Comments:

Article
Nominator:
 * Comments:

Supporters:
 * Comments:

Objectors:
 * Comments: